In November 2022, researchers typed ‘hypoallergenic’ into the search box on the websites of the chemists Boots and Superdrug and collected the ingredient lists of the products that came back.1 The search turned up 206 products, and 79 of them, or 38%, contained at least one of the skin allergens on a list known as the baseline series.1 Fragrance, which labels call ‘parfum’, was listed in 85 of the 206 products.1
In the UK there is no official standard for what makes a product hypoallergenic.1 So ‘hypoallergenic’ on the front is the maker's own description, and nothing guarantees the product is free of ingredients that can set off an allergy. YAN's view: a word that promises gentleness is not evidence of it, so we judge a skin product by what its ingredient list leaves out, not by what the front of the pack claims.
What you need to know
- Turn the pack over: the ingredient list tells you more than the word on the front, so check it for ‘parfum’ or ‘fragrance’.
- If a doctor has named an ingredient you are allergic to, keep its name in your phone and check every new product for it, whatever the front says.
- No need to bin a product that suits your skin; the word only matters when you choose something new.
What did the dermatologists say?
Prof Mabs Chowdhury said shoppers are entitled to a plain expectation: “it is reasonable for users to expect that these products will be unlikely to cause an allergic reaction.”1 Prof Chowdhury added that it was “hard to see how products containing ingredients such as formaldehyde releasers, methylisothiazolinone, and fragrances such as limonene and linalool could possibly be described as hypoallergenic.”1 Formaldehyde releasers and methylisothiazolinone are preservatives, added to stop a product going off.
Dr Siwaporn Hiranput, one of the researchers, said: “Our research suggests that some brands understate or downplay what constitutes a hypoallergenic product.”1 Dr Hiranput also said: “Clearer regulation or better enforcement of the existing rules is needed.”1
Who decides what the word means?
One reporter asked seven major manufacturers what made their products hypoallergenic, and the answers ranged from a short list of ingredients to a reply that the information is not disclosed.2 At one end, a publicist for Novartis said its Keri lotion qualified “because it is fragrance free and contains ingredients such as vitamins E and Aloe Vera.”2 Leaving out fragrance is a real step; adding vitamins and aloe says nothing about whether skin will react.
At the other end, Johnson & Johnson replied: “J&J does not disclose that info.”2 That reply shows only that the company did not share its basis, and tells us nothing about whether evidence exists. One person the reporter interviewed summed up the rules: “Unless the product makes a medical claim, the definition of ‘hypoallergenic’ is entirely up to the company that makes the product.”2 Another person the reporter interviewed said where that leaves shoppers: “People think ‘hypoallergenic’ means there are no allergens.”2
When a regulator tried to pin it down
America's Food and Drug Administration (FDA) once proposed a rule for the word: a cosmetic could be labelled “hypoallergenic” if “scientific studies” showed it caused reactions significantly less often than each product it was compared with.3 The FDA's regulation was challenged in court, and on appeal the judges reversed the ruling that had gone the FDA's way.3 As a result of the decision, manufacturers may continue to label their cosmetics “hypoallergenic” without any supporting evidence.4
In a consumer article from the time, which its website still carries, the FDA spelled out the result: makers could go on labelling their cosmetics hypoallergenic “without any supporting evidence”.4 Its web page still says there are “no Federal standards or definitions” for the word, that makers are not required to submit their evidence to the agency, and that “The term means whatever a particular company wants it to mean.”4
What Europe's rules ask of a maker
In the EU, the proof behind a claim like ‘hypoallergenic’ has to exist: every cosmetic claim must be backed by “adequate and verifiable evidence”, kept in the maker's product information file.5 That file stays with the maker, so a shopper at the shelf sees the word and never the proof. Yet the same rules say they are not meant to define the wording of claims, so nothing in them says what ‘hypoallergenic’ must mean.5
One published guide to the word says a product called hypoallergenic should leave out known allergens entirely, including substances for which the data on their power to start an allergy are missing.6 Even then, the summary says, the word “does not guarantee a complete absence of risk of an allergic reaction”.6 The guidance is not legally binding.6,7 That means a maker can still use the word without meeting this test.
In an EU-wide report on how cosmetic claims are checked, seven member states said they had found ‘hypoallergenic’ claims made “without supporting documents or evidence”.8
What makers' own tests check
One paper, with an author from the skin-care company Galderma, looked at ten skincare products tested on over 2,000 people in repeat insult patch tests.9 This kind of test checks two things: whether a product irritates the skin, and its potential for sensitization.9 A product counted as hypoallergenic “if there was no evidence of sensitization or allergic reactions”.9 That tells you whether a product started new allergies in the people tested; how it behaves on skin that is already sensitive is a separate question. The authors themselves wrote that “the scientific community has yet to identify an acceptable screening test for sensitive skin”.9
This investigation continues below.
Want the next one in your inbox?
Why it matters for skin that reacts
A contact allergy is the kind where the skin's defences learn to react to one ingredient, and the EU's scientific advisers on cosmetics call it “life-long”.10 The same advisers say allergy to fragrance ingredients “is most often caused by cosmetic products”, and usually shows on the face or hands.10 So an allergen in a cream will not set off an allergy in everyone who uses it. But because a contact allergy lasts for life, avoiding one in the first place is exactly what the word ‘hypoallergenic’ ought to help with. The same advisers call ingredient information “a cornerstone” of preventing these allergies.10
What nobody has tested
The UK audit worked from the ingredient lists on two retailers' websites.1 An ingredient list shows what is in a product, not how much of each ingredient, and not who reacts to it. The FDA's decades-old consumer article says the agency knew of no scientific studies showing that ‘hypoallergenic’ cosmetics actually cause fewer adverse reactions than conventional products.4 So the evidence tells us what goes into these products, while the question that matters most for sensitive skin, whether the word means fewer rashes, is still unanswered.
We would think better of the word if a study comparing products with and without it showed fewer reactions in people with sensitive skin or eczema, or if the leave-out-known-allergens test became law and was checked.
What to choose
- Beyond ‘parfum’, look further down the list for named scent chemicals such as limonene and linalool.
- We prefer a short ingredient list: each ingredient left out is one fewer chance of meeting the one your skin reacts to.
- Try a new product on a small patch of skin, such as the inside of your forearm, for a few days before it goes on your face or a child's skin.
- With hair dye, a pack that hints at lower allergy risk is no reason to skip the skin test in the instructions; look for phenylenediamine and resorcinol on the list.
- If a rash keeps coming back where a product touches, stop using it and ask your GP about patch testing, which can identify the ingredient behind it.
- If you want to ask the seller one thing, ask: “Which known allergens did you leave out to call this hypoallergenic?”
That is why we read the ingredient list before the front of the pack: it is the best guide a shopper has to what their skin will meet.