One at a time, disposables look cheap: Edinburgh's council puts them at 16p to 28p each, plus much more for eco brands.1 But on average a baby needs at least 4,000 nappy changes over the 2.5 years they spend in nappies.2
Add it all up and Edinburgh's council puts a child's nappies at £800 to £1,200 if they are disposable, against £200 to £400 if they are reusable.1 Because that money leaves your account one pack at a time, it never looks like a big bill.
Then there is the bin: disposable nappies make up about 4% of the general rubbish councils collect in England, and their disposal costs councils over £60 million a year, according to 2016 figures.3 So the price on the pack is only part of the bill: the rest comes out of council budgets that every household pays into, baby or not.
YAN's view: for most families, a nappy you wash and use again is a better choice than one you buy, use once and then pay for again, through the council, to throw away, as long as you dry it without a tumble dryer where you can.
This report is about money and waste: none of the studies here compared what each type does to a baby's skin.
What you need to know
- On council estimates, reusable nappies save a family several hundred pounds per child.1
- The bill for binning disposables falls on councils, so every household shares it.
- On the environment it is a trade-off: one review found reusables had lower impacts in some categories and disposables in more of them.4
- Drying matters: tumble drying can increase the carbon footprint of reusables.4
- The cheapest way in is a second-hand set, a council voucher if yours offers one, and a washing line.
What reusables cost to run
Reusables turn that pattern around: you pay most of the cost at the start, then a little each week in washing. Edinburgh's council guide says you can pick up a set that will do the whole two and a half years for £50.1
Every wash also uses electricity, and a tumble dryer uses far more, which shows up on the energy bill.
Edinburgh's guide calls its figures a rough estimate.1 We have not found a current, independent costing for a real family that counts the nappies, washing, water and energy together; if one showed the washing eats the saving, we would change our advice.
Who pays for the bin
Counts of that slice have disagreed wildly: a government Strategy Unit report put disposable nappies at some 2.4% of all landfilled material, while a letter questioning government spending on cloth nappy schemes put them at just 0.1% of total solid landfill waste.5,6 Those two counts are more than twenty times apart, which is how the same bin can be made to look trivial or sizeable. A 2016 estimate measured something different again: disposable nappies made up about 4% of the leftover (residual) rubbish that councils collect in England.3 That is a share of household bins rather than of all landfill, so it cannot settle which of the two landfill counts is right.
The councils that pay for disposal clearly treat it as sizeable, which is why some of them pay families to switch. Hackney Council, for one, once offered parents a £54 voucher to help get them started with cloth nappies.7
In one scheme across nine London councils, real nappy vouchers cost £29k and, by the count of Real Nappies for London, which issued them, saved the councils £321k.3 That is about eleven pounds back for every pound spent, because each family that switches keeps thousands of nappies out of the council's bin.
Real Nappies for London says the scheme offers 'financial savings to Local Authorities and to families, especially in times of austerity.'3
A review of the scheme notes that its impact estimates assume parents redeeming vouchers use reusable nappies from birth to toilet training.8 Families who mix in disposables keep fewer nappies out of the bin, so treat that eleven-to-one payback as the best case.
Are reusable nappies really greener?
A UK life cycle assessment, which weighs a product's harm to the environment from making to binning, found that overall no system clearly had a better or worse environmental impact.9,10 Critics called the research behind it 'seriously flawed' for concentrating on energy use without highlighting waste or landfill impacts.6
For disposables, research routinely finds that making them, starting with the raw materials, has the highest impact of any stage.4 Reusables are made once and then washed again and again, so how they are washed and dried matters. Tumble drying is the step to watch: it can increase the resulting carbon footprint.4
Across 18 impact categories, each a different kind of environmental harm, a research review for the Scottish Government found reusables showed lower impacts in only 7, while disposables remained lower in the remaining 11.4 Real Nappies for London, the group that issued the vouchers, says reusable nappies have a 25% lower carbon footprint than single-use nappies, and are still the best choice for the environment 'even when factoring in washing and drying'.2,3
This investigation continues below.
Want the next one in your inbox?
Both can be true at once: reusables tend to come out ahead on carbon, disposables on more of the other measures, and drying on a line rather than in a tumble dryer is what protects the reusable's carbon edge.
Are they more work?
In one trial described in the Scottish review, parents spent 29 minutes a day on nappies with reusables against 24 with disposables, and had 0.5 leaks a day against 0.2.8 Their water use was 15% higher while they were using reusables.8
That is about five extra minutes a day and one more leak every few days: real, but small enough for many families to live with.
The same review found that potential cost savings are often not seen as persuasive enough to overcome the barriers to using reusables.4 Yet money matters to those who do switch: in a 2005 UK survey, 68% of reusable users gave being cheaper or more economical as a reason.4
What to choose
On cost and waste, disposables are the worse option: you pay for every one, and your council pays again to get rid of it. Reusables are better, but not free of costs: they take water, electricity and a few more minutes a day, and a tumble dryer eats into their carbon edge. We prefer reusables dried on a line or an airer, because something you use for years and can pass on beats something made to be thrown away after one use.
- Start small: a few reusables a day at home still cuts what you buy and what goes in the bin.
- Check your council's website for a real-nappy voucher, discount or trial kit before you spend anything.
- Buy second-hand, and sell or pass the set on when you are done.
- Dry on a line or an airer, wash full loads, and keep the tumble dryer for when nothing else works.
- Choose plain cotton nappies with no 'stain-resistant' or 'easy care' claim, and wash new ones before first use.
- If you can't face the washing, ask whether a nappy laundry service covers your area and what it charges; it still keeps nappies out of the bin.
- If you stay with disposables, don't pay extra for an 'eco' label on trust; nothing in this research shows what the higher price buys.
- Never put disposable nappies on a garden compost heap, even ones sold as compostable.
If you also want a waterproof cover, check the product page for the words "PFAS-free". PFAS are a large family of very long-lasting chemicals, often called "forever chemicals", that makers use to help fabric shrug off water and stains. We have not tested covers ourselves, so treat "PFAS-free" as a good sign rather than proof, and skip a cover sold only as "PFOA-free": PFOA is just one chemical in that family, so the label says nothing about the rest. Whichever route you take, remember that the bin lorry is part of the price.