Updated 24 October 2026.
You are scrolling and a video stops you: someone in their own kitchen, talking to the camera about a thing they love, as easily as a friend passing on a tip. That is the whole problem: the more a paid video feels like a friend’s honest tip, the easier it is to miss the advert inside it.
In 2025 the UK’s advertising regulator, the ASA, asked 1,900 people across the UK to take part in an exercise it called “Spot the Sell”.1 Faced with adverts made by brands, 74% picked “Definitely an ad”; faced with adverts made by influencers, only 54% did.1
YAN’s view: treat any video that shows off a product as possible advertising, label or no label, and let the facts about the product, not the warmth of the person holding it, decide what you buy.
What you need to know
- In the UK, a post that has been paid for or rewarded with free gifts must be clearly identifiable as advertising.2,3
- Adverts made by creators are often more difficult to recognise as advertising than other kinds of online advertising.4
- Before you buy, look for “Ad”, “#ad” or “Paid partnership” at the start of the post, then judge the product on its own page, not on the person showing it.
Why a creator can feel like a friend
Researchers call this pull parasocial interaction: the feeling of being in a give-and-take relationship with someone on screen, even though the exchange runs only one way.5 Donald Horton and R. Richard Wohl introduced the idea in 1956, decades before anyone filmed a product review on a phone.5 A creator who talks to you from their own kitchen, in their own words, week after week, fits that one-sided friendship closely: you know their voice and their home, and they have never met you.
Around a third of the UK online population say they actively follow influencers for recommendations, according to the ASA’s latest research.6 An earlier questionnaire by the CMA, the UK’s competition and consumer watchdog, found that social media endorsements influence buying decisions, and that people often look to social media channels for opinions and reviews before they buy.3
An old idea was that lonely viewers form these one-sided bonds to make up for missing company, but the evidence has not consistently supported it, and one study found no link between loneliness and parasocial interaction.5 So the pull is not a sign that something is wrong with the viewer; anyone who watches a friendly face often enough can feel it.
What the tests show
The ASA’s chief executive, Guy Parker, has put it plainly: “The research tells us that all of us can find it hard to identify when an influencer is advertising, so it’s crucial that ads are labelled clearly.”7
The ASA’s tests found the mix-ups go both ways: people took some genuine reviews for adverts, and some paid posts for ordinary, unpaid content.6 The second mistake is the one that costs shoppers, because a paid post taken for an honest opinion borrows a friend’s credibility without a friend’s independence.
The regulator’s own advice says ads that are very similar in tone or voice to an influencer’s usual posts are very likely to need a label.8 In other words, the more natural the advert, the more the label matters.
It also advises against vague labels such as “sponsored”, because the word is open to varied interpretation.8 Shahriar Coupal, the ASA’s Director of Advertising Policy and Practice, says a plain label is what people want: “Our research shows strong public support for clear, upfront ad labelling, which helps people make informed choices and trust the content they see.”6
How often the label is missing
One sweep checked the posts of 576 influencers on major social media platforms.9 Nearly all of them posted commercial content, but only one in five systematically made clear that it was advertising.9 Most of those checked were then earmarked for further investigation.9
The European Commission’s list of national cases includes a 2023 investigation into misleading information about food supplement products, which ended in a fine for an influencer.10 Supplements show why this matters: a health claim lands harder when it comes from someone you feel you know.
Who has to label a paid post, and who answers for it
Hidden advertising is illegal in the UK, and European consumer law already says brand partnerships, content made in exchange for products and affiliate marketing must be disclosed.3,10 Working with brands is allowed: the ASA says there is nothing wrong with influencers entering into commercial relationships, but consumers must not be misled.8
The CMA has had 16 influencers give undertakings, formal promises, to make it clear when they have been paid or otherwise incentivised to endorse a product.3 It also investigated Instagram, concerned that the platform was not doing enough to stop people promoting businesses without saying they had been paid or sent free gifts.3 Those words “free gifts” matter: a parcel in the post counts, not only a fee.
In EU law, influencers who regularly advertise or sell products are categorised as traders: in the eyes of the law, they are in business, not just sharing.10 The law firm Osborne Clarke reads the European guidance the same way: any reward makes a post commercial, from payment and discounts to commission from affiliate links (a cut of each sale made through the creator’s link) and free products, including unsolicited gifts.4
This investigation continues below.
Want the next one in your inbox?
The firm adds that brand owners commissioning or benefiting from the advert can be liable as well as the influencer.4 In the UK, the ASA typically treats the brand as at least jointly responsible for posts by its affiliates, whether or not it was aware of them or had control over them.11 So the creator and the brand both answer for a missing label, whether the reward was a fee or a free sample.
In several cases, posts included only an @ mention or a tag of the brand, which the ASA did not consider sufficient to identify the post as an ad.11 So a brand’s name in the caption tells you there may be a deal, not that the post has been labelled.
What nobody has measured, and what a video leaves out
The research above tests whether people can spot an ad, not how much more they trust a creator than a brand, and we found no study that measures that gap directly. So we can't tell you whether the popular claim that we trust creators more than adverts is true, because the research we found doesn't measure it. What the evidence does show is enough to act on: many of us miss paid posts, and the label is often absent.
Our advice would change if regular checks found paid posts reliably labelled, or if tests showed people spotting creators’ ads as easily as brands’ own.
A product video is good at showing how something looks and feels in someone’s hands in the first days of owning it. It rarely shows what the thing is made of, how long it lasts, whether it can be repaired, or where it ends up when you are done. We judge every product by exactly those questions, because something natural, repairable and recyclable keeps its value long after the excitement of the video fades.
What to check before you buy
This takes a minute, and the first steps are free.
- Check the start of the caption and the first seconds of the video for “Ad”, “#ad” or the platform’s own “Paid partnership” tag; a label you only find after tapping “See more” is too easy to miss.
- Read “sponsored”, “gifted”, “thanks to” or a bare @ mention as a sign of a deal, not a proper label.
- If there's a discount code or a shop link, the creator may earn something when you buy, so weigh the praise with that in mind.
- If there’s no label at all, don’t take that as proof the video is unpaid.
- Open the product’s own page and look for what it is made of, the guarantee, the returns policy and whether repairs or spare parts are offered.
- If you spot an obvious ad with no label, report it to the ASA in the UK or to your national consumer authority in the EU.
- Sleep on anything you only met in a video: if you still want it tomorrow, you are choosing the product, not the moment.
A clearly labelled ad is the honest version of that friendly video; the worse one is the same video with no label, because it asks for a friend’s trust while keeping the deal out of sight.