Skip to main content
You're A Natural
Editorial artwork for Old electronics can end up in a black plastic spatula, and the label may not tell youMaterial

Material

Old electronics can end up in a black plastic spatula, and the label may not tell you

A 2024 study's dose warning rested on a missing zero, but the fire-safety chemicals it found in about one black item in ten were real.

Recycled black plastic can carry fire-safety chemicals from old TVs into kitchen tools. The dose was overstated; the gap in the checks is real. Here is what to stir hot food with instead.

YAN Editorial
Published: 8 June 2026Last updated: 24 October 202610 min read14 sources1,889 words...

Listen for Context

The report distills the story. The podcast gives it more room, with two hosts unpacking the evidence, background, and data behind the findings.

Updated 24 October 2026.

Researchers screened 203 black plastic products sold in the US, from sushi take-out trays to toy necklaces but mostly kitchenware, and found 17 of them contaminated with high levels of flame retardants, the chemicals added to plastic to slow a fire.1,2 Kitchen utensils were among the products that screened high for bromine, the element at the heart of one family of flame retardants.2,3 The results showed that electronics containing flame retardants, such as the outer casings of large TVs, are being recycled into food storage containers and utensils.4

So recycled black plastic can carry flame retardants from old electronics into a kitchen tool, and even the type of plastic printed on the label is often wrong.4,5 When the researchers screened the products for bromine, it turned up at more than 50 parts per million in 20 of them, including 9 kitchen utensils and 2 pieces of food service ware.2 Most of those bromine-positive samples also held flame retardants.2 What that means for your health is less clear: the authors corrected an early mistake that had overstated how much a cook might swallow, and whether flame retardants in a cooking utensil pose any health threat is still unclear.1,6

YAN's view: a chemical made to stop televisions catching fire has no place in a spoon that sits in your dinner, and a harm nobody has proven is not the same as safety, so for hot food we choose wood or stainless steel over plastic.

What you need to know

  • Some black plastic kitchen tools are made partly from the recycled casings of old electronics, which can carry flame retardants.4,7
  • In the US study, 17 of 203 products made partly or completely of black plastics were contaminated with high levels of flame retardants.1,2
  • In a separate lab check, 26 spatulas from the EU market were tested for the substances found in the US, and all of them were fine.8
  • The study's dose warning rested on a miscalculated limit; corrected, the estimated dose is not close to it.6,9
  • For hot food, use a wooden spoon or stainless steel marked 304 or 316, and keep plastic tools for cold jobs.
  • There's no need to bin a black spatula today: stop leaving it in hot pans and replace it when you can.

How old TV casings end up in a kitchen drawer

Recycling plants sort plastic with infrared light, but black plastic does not reflect infrared light, which makes it “invisible” to the detector.7,9 So black plastic is not readily recycled, and there is mounting evidence that the demand for it in consumer goods is partly met with the plastic housings of old electrical and electronic equipment.7 Those casings often contain flame retardants, which can remain in the recycled plastic, and contamination has turned up in black goods from thermos cups and cutlery to tool handles.4,7,10

The black colour itself comes from carbon black, a pigment made by charring organic matter such as wood in the absence of air.9 The black is only pigment; the concern is the plastic's earlier life.

Most of the contaminated products held deca-BDE, an old flame retardant that has been phased out in the US, EU and China.1,2,4 Companies have since moved to alternatives that may also be hazardous, so a tool free of deca-BDE is not automatically clean.3 “Companies continue to use toxic flame retardants in plastic electronics, and that’s resulting in unexpected and unnecessary toxic exposures,” said Megan Liu, the study's co-author and science and policy manager at Toxic-Free Future.4

How much gets from the spoon into the food?

In a 2018 study, the researcher Harrad and his colleagues found that uptake through the skin from simply holding black plastic cooking utensils was negligible.1 Heat changed that: when bits of black plastic sat in hot olive oil, about 20 percent of the flame retardants in a utensil transferred into the oil on average.1,9 Heat and time in the pan move the chemicals, so a spoon left standing in a hot pot matters more than a quick stir.

That test soaked pieces of plastic in hot oil, which is harsher than stirring a pan, so it shows how the chemicals move rather than how much a cook takes in. Harrad's own advice is to avoid leaving a black plastic utensil in a hot pan or pot for long periods of time.1

What the 2024 study got wrong about the dose

The paper had warned that the dose from using contaminated utensils “would approach” the safe daily limit, or reference dose, set by the US Environmental Protection Agency.6 But the authors had miscalculated that limit, putting it at 42,000 nanograms a day instead of 420,000.6 In other words, a zero had gone missing, which made the limit look ten times stricter than it is. With the zero restored, the estimated dose was about one-tenth of the reference dose, and a second correction lowered the estimate further still.6,9

What the checks cover, and where they stop

In the US, the Food and Drug Administration looks at recycled plastic for food use case by case and gives informal advice on whether a recycling process makes it clean enough, and that guidance is not legally enforceable.10,11 None of the 11 flame retardants found in the study is regulated in recycled plastic products in the US.12 The same study found that makers often get the type of plastic on the label wrong, so the label is not a reliable guide either.5

On a kitchen tool, “recycled” says where the plastic came from, and “food-safe” alone does not say anyone looked for chemicals from old electronics.

In Europe, testers sent 26 spatulas sold on the EU market, among them models from Temu, Ikea, Tefal and WMF, to a lab to look specifically for the chemicals found in the US, and all were fine.8 And when the reviewers at Americas Test Kitchen asked the makers of their top-rated plastic tools, OXO, Matfer Bourgeat and Cuisinart, each confirmed it uses no recycled plastic.5

What about wooden spoons?

Wooden and bamboo tools sidestep this problem: as the Americas Test Kitchen reviewers put it, these natural materials “aren’t at risk for flame retardant contamination.”5 The catch is the finish, because wood is often lacquered to stop it breaking down from contact with liquids or sharp objects.13 With a wooden spoon, the finish is the part to choose with care.

This investigation continues below.

Want the next one in your inbox?

One study looked at 72 wood and 29 stainless steel chopsticks with different colors, and found high metal concentrations in red and green paints on the stainless ones, while paints on wood chopsticks showed lower metal concentrations.14 For chopsticks, plain unpainted ones are the simple choice; painted steel pairs, especially red or green ones, are the ones to skip.

Choose a spoon carved from solid wood or bamboo, either unfinished or from a maker who names the finish, rather than a smooth moulded “bamboo” one. Don't leave it standing in very hot food for long, and when it looks dry, rub in food-grade raw linseed or tung oil, never “boiled” linseed oil. An unfinished wooden spoon is wholly natural, so at the end of its life it can go on the home compost heap.

What nobody has tested

The EU test is good news for the 26 spatulas it covered, but 26 is a small sample, and it cannot tell you where a tool on another shelf came from. Nothing in this evidence shows how pale recycled plastic behaves in hot food, nothing in it covers UK rules or tools on UK shelves, and nothing gives shoppers a mark that says whether the recycled plastic in a kitchen tool went through a clean-up check. An older overview of food packaging found no studies available in the public domain on what moves out of wooden food contact materials into food, and no specific measures had been enacted for wood as a food contact material.13 A large test of recycled-plastic kitchen tools on UK shelves, coming back as clean as the EU spatulas, would ease the concern about black plastic, and a test of wood finishes in hot food would tell us whether to be pickier about wooden spoons.

What to stir hot food with

Start with the free habit: if your spatula is plastic, don't leave it resting in a hot pan or a simmering pot; stir, then lift it out. Keep plastic tools, pale or black, for cold jobs such as salads, spreading and scooping.

A black tool of unknown make, with no brand and no word on what it is made of, is the worse option, because nothing tells you whether it began life as a television casing. A plastic tool from a maker that says plainly it uses no recycled plastic is better than that, though it is still plastic. If the packaging doesn't say, one question to the seller helps: “Is this tool made with any recycled plastic?”

For hot food, at YAN we prefer a wooden spoon (unfinished, or one whose maker names the finish, and not left stirring very hot food for long) or stainless steel marked 304 or 316 on the item or product page. Buy the steel from a seller who will take it back, and when it finally wears out it can go for scrap.

If you can't replace a black spatula yet, use it only for quick jobs, and retire first any that is melted, chipped or warped. When it is due for replacing, don't swap it for another black tool with no maker's name.

These chemicals are still turning up in new goods that contain recycled plastics, so the problem has not been sorted out yet.1 Until it is, reach for a wooden spoon or a stainless steel spatula marked 304 or 316 whenever the food is hot.

...

Read next

The Forensic Specimen (Low Poly) illustration showing cheap for report Not all ‘food-grade’ stainless steel is equal, and ...Material

Not all ‘food-grade’ stainless steel is equal, and cheap grades are being sold as the good ones

What the grade numbers on pots, flasks and bottles mean, what tests show about metal getting into food, and how to choose steel that lasts.

The Dissolution (Pointillism) illustration showing plastic for report A Recycled Plastic Claim Does Not Tell You If the Pa...Philosophy

A Recycled Plastic Claim Does Not Tell You If the Pack Will Be Recycled

England collects little household film for recycling, showing why a recycling route needs compatible design, sorting capacity and a reliable end market.

Artwork for Flame retardants in UK sofas get into dust, but a sofa of natural materials passed the fire test without themMaterial

Flame retardants in UK sofas get into dust, but a sofa of natural materials passed the fire test without them

Why a 1988 fire test filled British sofa foam with flame retardants, how they reach people through household dust, and the simple steps that cut your exposure now.

Editorial artwork for The BPA-Free TrapMaterial

The BPA-Free Trap

"BPA-free" certifies the absence of one molecule, not the absence of the hazard. Here's what replaced it, why the label can't name it, and how to read past the badge.